Hermès has won its yearlong lawsuit against Mason Rothschild over what it considered an infringement of its intellectual property.
Rothschild created MetaBirkins, which depicted the brand’s Birkin bags, without the permission of the parent company, Hermès. It collected over 200 ETH during the sale. According to a Financial Times report, the Italian brand won the trial in New York on Wednesday, with Rothschild ordered to pay $133,000 in damages.
Rothschild’s lawyer argued that their client’s work should be protected under the right to artistic expression under the U.S. Constitution’s First Amendment. They compared his art with Andy Warhol’s silk-screen prints of Campbell’s soup cans.
Blake Gopnik, the author of Warhol’s biography, could have linked the similarities between the artworks. But, to Rothschild’s dismay, Gopnik could not attend the testimony.
Hermès’ lawyers claimed that Rothschild stole the goodwill of their “famous intellectual property to create and sell his own line of products.” They further pointed toward the similarity of the website URLs that might confuse the users.
Jonathan Harris, one of Rothschild’s lawyers, said: “The decision marked a good day for luxury brands and a bad day for artists.” It is worth noting that Rothschild didn’t create any tangible Birkin-type bags; he just took the bag as an inspiration and created digital art.
Luxury brands have been keeping an eye on this case since 2022. As a result, Rolex, Nike, and many other brands filed for trademarks to offer NFTs and metaverse services in 2022.
BeInCrypto has reached out to company or individual involved in the story to get an official statement about the recent developments, but it has yet to hear back.